Wick & Weigh

Wicks & fixes · October 24, 2026

Comparing two wick tests: what to write down before you change the recipe

7 minute read

Two test candles burning side by side on a tray, with a steel ruler and a burn-test notebook

One wick test tells you which wick worked for one candle. The trouble starts with the second test. You change the fragrance, or try a new jar, or a new bag of wax arrives. You test again, and a different wick wins. Was it the change, or was it something you didn’t notice?

You can only answer that if the two tests were run the same way and written down the same way. This guide is a checklist for that. It assumes you already know how to run a single test. If not, start with how to run a wick test and come back.

The example we will use

Say your candle is Golden Brands 464 soy in a jar with a 3 inch inside diameter. The wick test planner takes that wax and diameter from the CandleScience chart and suggests CD 18, so the first test is CD 16, CD 18 and CD 20. CD 18 gives the cleanest burn, and that becomes your recipe.

A month later you want to switch to a heavier vanilla oil at the same 8% load. The fair question is: does CD 18 still work, or should you move to CD 16 or CD 20? To answer it, the second test has to match the first everywhere except the oil.

Checklist 1: what has to match between the two tests

Go through this before you pour test two. Anything you can’t match, write down, because it is a second change hiding inside your test.

  • Wax: same wax, and ideally the same bag or lot. CandleScience recommends re-testing existing candles at the start of each season, or at least twice a year, because soy and other natural waxes vary from batch to batch. A new bag is a small change, but it is still a change.
  • Fragrance load, and what it is a percentage of: 8% of the wax and 8% of the finished candle are different amounts of oil. Use the same basis both times. See fragrance load, explained.
  • Dye: same dye and the same amount. Dye can change the burn, and the CandleScience wick guide the planner uses was built with no dye at 7.5% fragrance.
  • Jar: same jar model. Measure the inside diameter at the widest point, not the number printed on the box.
  • Fill weight: the same fill line. A jar poured fuller starts its first burns further from the rim and heats differently near the end.
  • Pour temperature and cooling: same pour temperature for your wax, and cool in the same place.
  • Cure time: count days from the pour and match them. CandleScience’s minimum before a burn test is 24 hours. Many soy makers wait longer, but the important thing is that both tests waited the same number of days.
  • Room: the same spot, free of drafts, with candles three to six inches apart, which is the spacing CandleScience gives for testing several at once.
  • Trim and burn length: trim every wick to ¼ inch before each lighting, and burn for the same length every time. CandleScience’s method is up to four hours, then at least five hours to cool.

If two or more of these changed, the second test is no longer a test of the oil. It is a new test of a new candle. That is fine, but compare it to nothing.

Checklist 2: what to record at every check

CandleScience suggests checking each candle every hour and keeping notes on a card or in a notebook. Use the same columns both times so you can lay the two logs side by side. This is the one table in this guide:

Field How to record it Why it matters
Burn cycle and hour “Burn 3, hour 4” Early burns look different from late ones
Distance from melt pool to glass Inches or mm, with a ruler CandleScience’s target: no more than ¼ in from the edge at three to four hours
Melt pool depth Inches or mm CandleScience gives ¼ to ½ in as typical
Flame height Inches, against the ruler About 1 in is common; up to 2 in can be normal
Flame movement Still, flickering, dancing Movement can be a draft, not the wick
Soot None, occasional, heavy, on glass Heavy, frequent soot can mean wick down
Mushrooming None, small, large, carbon dropping A large mushroom can mean wick down
Warning signs Tall or restless flame, smoke, soot, very fast melt Look, never touch: heat builds as the wax gets lower
Photo Same angle, ruler in frame Lets you compare by eye months later

Write the time you lit each candle, and note anything unusual in the room: a window open, the heating on, a fan.

Checklist 3: when you are allowed to compare

Comparing too early is the most common way two tests mislead you.

  • Not before the fourth burn. CandleScience says to wait until at least the fourth burn cycle before judging a wick. Melt pools form slowly in the first few burns and faster as the wax gets lower.
  • Burn hour against burn hour. Burn 3, hour 4 of test one compares with burn 3, hour 4 of test two. Don’t compare one test’s first evening with the other’s fifth.
  • The whole jar. CandleScience’s method keeps going until about ¼ inch of wax is left, because the bottom of the jar is where an oversized wick shows: more heat, a livelier flame, a hotter glass.
  • No swapping mid-test. If one wick is clearly wrong, finish it or stop that candle. Don’t put a new wick into a used candle. A burning wick soaks up wax, oil and dye, so a new wick in an old candle doesn’t burn like it would in a fresh one.
  • Scent last. CandleScience advises finishing the wick test before you judge hot throw, and testing scent separately with one candle in a controlled room. Several candles burning together make a poor scent test.

Reading the comparison

Put the two logs side by side, burn by burn. You are looking for a pattern that holds across several burns, not one odd evening.

The change helped or made no difference: the same wick gives a pool that reaches within ¼ inch of the glass by hours three to four from the fourth burn on, with a steady flame and little soot. Keep the wick.

The new candle runs hotter: in test two the same wick shows taller flames, more soot on the glass, bigger mushrooms, or a hotter rim than in test one. Look at the next size down in the test. CandleScience notes that soot can also come from a fragrance load that is too high or from certain oils, so check the load before blaming the wick.

The new candle runs cooler: a ring of wax is still on the glass after the fourth burn where test one had none. Look at the next size up. A small amount of wax left on the glass in early burns is normal and usually melts in later ones.

If the logs disagree in both directions, with more soot and also a narrower pool, check the list in Checklist 1 again. That usually means something else changed. The candle troubleshooter lists the common causes of each problem.

One change at a time

If you change the oil and the jar together and a new wick wins, you won't know which change caused it. Change one thing, test it, write it down, and only then change the next.

Keeping the logs useful

A burn log is only useful if you can find it again. Give each test a short code (date plus candle, for example “2026-10 vanilla 3in”) and write it on the base of every jar, on the notecards and on the photo filenames. Keep the winning recipe on one line: wax, oil and load with its basis, dye and amount, jar, wick, pour temperature, cure days.

Then when the next bag of wax arrives or a supplier changes a formula, you already know what to compare against.

Honest limits

Everything above comes from published supplier guidance. A wick chart and a test planner only give a starting point. Your wax, oil, dye and jar decide the result, and only a full burn test shows it. Never leave a burning test candle unattended.

Sources

  • CandleScience: how to conduct a basic burn test, for the 24-hour minimum cure, ¼ in trim, 3 to 6 in spacing, four-hour burns and five-hour cooling, melt pool and flame targets, the fourth-burn rule, no wick swaps mid-test, hot throw after the wick test, and seasonal re-testing
  • CandleScience: wick guide, the starting wicks the planner uses

Work it out for your own candles

Wick Test PlannerCandle Troubleshooter

Photo credits: Roman Mesyancev · Abigail Ybarra · Jessica Mangano · Mustafi Numann · Allison Saeng · User_Pascal · Maria Kovalets on Unsplash