“Soy or coconut?” is hard to answer in the abstract, because the coconut waxes sold to hobbyists are mostly blends. A more useful question is how two specific products differ, so this guide compares CandleScience’s SimplySoy Artisan Wax with its Coconut Apricot Wax, using the supplier’s own product pages and lab notes as they read on November 7, 2026. Everything below is the supplier’s published information, not our burn testing.
The side-by-side
| SimplySoy Artisan | Coconut Apricot | |
|---|---|---|
| Listed ingredients | Soy | Apricot, coconut, paraffin, soy |
| Melt point | 122 to 128°F | 121 to 131°F |
| Listed pour temperature | 160°F | 170°F |
| Best tops in supplier tests | 160°F, plus or minus 5°F | 175°F, plus or minus 5°F |
| Container fragrance load on product page | 10% | 10% |
| Wick series recommended | CD, LX | AL, CD, LX |
| Cure guidance | At least two days | One to two days |
| Price per lb, smallest bag | $4.79 | $5.37 |
The two waxes are close on paper. The melt points overlap, and the pour temperatures are only 10°F apart. The bigger differences are in what the wax is made of, how it behaves in the jar, and how much wick it wants.
Coconut Apricot is a blend, not pure coconut
The product page lists apricot, coconut, paraffin and soy, and CandleScience describes it as a custom blend. It says the paraffin is key to the wax’s strong fragrance throw. That matters if you plan to call your candles “paraffin-free” or “100% natural.” Read the ingredient line for the exact product rather than assuming from the name. SimplySoy lists only soy, though it is also a formulated wax with additives meant to reduce frosting and improve glass adhesion.
Fragrance limits: two numbers, two meanings
Both product pages list 10% for containers. CandleScience’s lab notes for Coconut Apricot go further and say the wax held all of its test fragrance oils at up to 15%, while also warning that higher loads can lower the finished candle’s melting point and cause trouble when shipping in warm weather. The SimplySoy lab notes report the same result up to 10%.
Treat the product page as the working number and the 15% as a laboratory result, not a recipe. If you want to see what a load means in ounces, the fragrance oil per pound chart has it, and wax specs lists published limits for other waxes.
Surface, frosting and glass
CandleScience reports that SimplySoy’s additives reduced frosting in its tests, with four of six fragrances showing none, and that it recommends a refinishing step for the smoothest top. For Coconut Apricot it says it saw no frosting in its test candles, while noting that frosting is always possible with natural blends. The Coconut Apricot lab notes also describe wet spots and pull-away from the glass in some candles, and say warming the jars or pouring warmer can help. Cold temperatures can make both waxes pull from the glass. Our guide on wet spots and frosting covers the fixes.
The wick is the part people miss
CandleScience says Coconut Apricot has a lower viscosity when liquid, so it travels up the wick faster and generally needs a smaller wick than soy to avoid feeding the flame too much fuel. That means a wick that works in SimplySoy should not be dropped straight into the blend. Keep the jar, fragrance, fill weight and room conditions the same, change only the wax, and run a fresh wick test for each. The wick test planner lays out a controlled comparison.
What the price gap means
At the smallest bag sizes the blend costs $0.58 more per pound. At larger sizes the gap is wider: SimplySoy was $2.89 per pound in a 10 lb bag, while Coconut Apricot was $4.10 per pound in an 11.3 lb slab. Those are snapshots that change with stock, sales and shipping, and the raw wax is only part of the cost of a finished candle. Plug your own invoice into the candle cost calculator, and include any extra test candles you pour while changing waxes.
Which to shortlist
If you want a soy-only ingredient list and the lower price per pound, start with SimplySoy and test your fragrances for frosting. If you want a single-pour wax the supplier describes as smooth-topped with strong throw, and you can live with a blend that contains paraffin and a higher price, shortlist Coconut Apricot. Either way, the best candle wax guide can help narrow the field, and your own burn tests decide.
Where this stops: the figures come from one supplier’s pages and its in-house lab, not independent testing, and they are specific to the fragrances, containers and conditions it used. Prices and product details can change, so check the current pages before you buy a case.