CD, ECO and LX are three different wick series, not three labels on one size scale. Within a series a bigger number means a bigger wick, but across series the numbers do not line up: CandleScience says an LX 22 may or may not be bigger than an ECO 8. So the first choice is a series that suits your wax, and the second is a size you confirm with a test burn. This guide works through the questions makers usually ask about the three.
What is each series, according to suppliers?
| Series | How suppliers describe it | Where they point it |
|---|---|---|
| CD (also sold as Stabilo) | Flat braided cotton with paper threads woven in; reinforced for a consistent burn at higher fragrance loads | CandleScience: soy wax and IGI 6046. Lone Star: harder, more viscous paraffin and vegetable waxes |
| ECO | Flat cotton braided with thin paper threads, rigid without a core; Lone Star adds that it is built to curl and self-trim | CandleScience: soy, plus IGI 6006 and 4627. Lone Star: soy and palm |
| LX | Flat braided cotton with a rigid structure and a tighter, controlled flame | CandleScience: paraffin (IGI 4625 and 4630) and some soy blends. Lone Star: paraffin and IGI 6006 |
The two suppliers do not always agree, and neither publishes the exact fibres in each series, so read the wick guide for the wax you actually buy.
Why can’t I convert an LX size to an ECO size?
Because the series are built differently, and there is no published formula between them. You can see this in our own wick data. In the CandleScience wick guide, a jar between 2.2 and 2.69 inches wide poured with Golden Brands 454 lists ECO 12 and LX 20 as two starting points for the same jar. The numbers are far apart even though both are meant to burn the same candle. The wick size chart shows these side by side for each wax and jar width.
The practical rule is to never carry a number from one series into another. If your ECO 10 works, that tells you nothing about which LX or CD will, so pick the new series’ starting size from the wick size chart for your wax and diameter.
Which series should I try first?
Start with the series your wax supplier lists. CandleScience’s guide, for example, lists CD and ECO for its soy waxes, and the wax specs page lists the waxes we track. If you pour paraffin or a paraffin blend, LX is a common candidate. If two series are listed for your wax, they are both reasonable starting points, and the test decides between them.
CandleScience’s picks come from lab burns with its own waxes, 1 oz of medium-density fragrance oil per pound of wax and a medium shade of dye. It advises going up a size or two for more fragrance, dense oils or lots of dye, and down a size or two for less than 1 oz per pound, thin fragrances or no dye. So the chart is a starting point for a recipe like that, not for every recipe.
A worked example with real chart numbers
Say you pour Golden Brands 464 soy into a jar that is 3 inches across. That falls in the 2.95 to 3.29 inch row of the CandleScience guide, which lists CD 18 and ECO 14. Those are two separate plans, not a conversion, so you would test them separately. For ECO you would try ECO 12, ECO 14 and ECO 16, and for CD you would try CD 16, CD 18 and CD 20. That is six candles in all, and you only need the second set if the first does not give a good burn.
A jar that sits between two rows belongs to the smaller row, which is also CandleScience’s advice for jars between sizes. Our wick test planner applies that rule for you. If your jar is wider than the chart goes, the guide lists multi-wick options instead of a single bigger wick.
What does “self-trimming” mean here?
Lone Star explains that flat braided wicks like CD, ECO and LX curl at the tip as they burn, which helps trim the wick in a container, while cored wicks keep a wick standing straight in a votive or pillar. It describes ECO as running low on soot and afterglow and LX as cutting mushrooming, smoke and soot. Those are the supplier’s descriptions of the construction. How much curl, soot or mushrooming you actually get still depends on the size, wax and fragrance, which is why the burn test matters more than the series name.
What about other series like AL?
CandleScience also sells an Aroma-Lite (AL) series, made in the USA from natural cotton, which it says unfurls slightly as it burns for a smaller, even flame and a larger, centered melt pool. It lists AL for its Coconut Apricot wax and for paraffin and paraffin blends. Lone Star adds HTP, a coreless cotton with paper filament, to its flat-braided families. The same rule applies to both: sizes in one series say nothing about sizes in another, so a newly added series starts its own test from the chart for your wax and jar.
How do I switch series without guessing?
Keep everything else fixed and change one thing at a time. The steps are:
- Pick the jar’s inside diameter and find the listed wicks for your wax in the chart.
- Choose one size below and one above the listed size, so you test three candidates in the series.
- Pour the same wax, fragrance, load, dye and fill weight into the same jar for each candidate.
- Burn each fully in a draft-free room, never leaving it unattended, and note the flame, melt pool and soot by eye, without touching the hot glass.
- Adjust a size and retest, or try another series from the supplier’s list if no size in this one works.
The wick test planner builds that three-size plan for you and gives a place to record each result.
When is it time to switch series?
Switch when no reasonable size in your current series gives a good burn, when the wax maker recommends a different series for the exact formula, or when the recipe changes in a big way, such as moving from soy to a blend or raising the fragrance load. A switch is a reason to start a new test, not a promise the new series will fix it. If several sizes in two series all fail, look at the fragrance load, jar width and wax before chasing more wicks.
Where this stops: this is a summary of what two suppliers publish about their wicks. It is not our testing, it is not independent, and it cannot predict how your wax, fragrance and jar will behave. Confirm every wick with your own burn test.
Work it out for your own candles
Wick Test Planner