Most pricing advice works out the cost of one candle: wax, oil, jar, wick, label, box, a few minutes of your time. Our own Etsy pricing walkthrough does exactly that and lands on $7.45 for a 7 oz soy candle.
That number is right for one candle. But you don’t make one candle. You make batches, and not every candle in a batch turns into a sale. This guide works through the costs that sit between “candles made” and “candles sold”, as questions and answers, with numbers from the candle cost calculator.
Which candles count as unsold?
Every candle you paid for that doesn’t bring in full price. The usual ones are:
- Samples: a candle left with a shop owner, sent to a stockist or given at a market so people can smell it.
- Test candles: jars poured to test a wick, oil or load. A three-wick test with two jars per wick is six candles that are never sold.
- Seconds: a sinkhole, a crack, a crooked wick or a bad label.
- Leftover stock: the holiday scent still on the shelf in January.
- Gifts and personal use. These count too, even if you’re happy to give them.
They all cost the same wax, oil, jar and time as the candles you sell. The only question is which candles pay for them.
How do I put unsold candles into the price?
Spread the cost of the whole batch over the candles you expect to sell:
cost per sold candle = cost per candle × candles made ÷ candles sold
The calculator has two fields for this: Candles made and Expected to sell. With the example candle at $7.45, a batch of 12 costs $89.44. Here is what happens as fewer of them sell. The prices are for a 50% margin on Etsy and use the same fee formula as our calculator:
| Sold out of 12 | Cost per sold candle | Price for a 50% margin on Etsy |
|---|---|---|
| 12 | $7.45 | $19.51 |
| 10 | $8.94 | $23.20 |
| 9 | $9.94 | $25.65 |
| 8 | $11.18 | $28.72 |
Two unsold jars out of twelve move the price you need by almost $3.70. Four unsold jars move it by more than $9.
Where do those Etsy prices come from?
Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee and a 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus any shipping you charge. In the US, payment processing for Etsy Payments is 3% plus $0.25, charged on the whole sale including tax and shipping. Our calculator treats that as $0.45 plus 9.5% of the price and leaves sales tax out, because the buyer pays it.
For a 50% margin, half the price is profit, 9.5% goes to fees, and the cost and fixed fees have to fit in what’s left:
price = (cost + $0.45) ÷ (1 − 0.095 − 0.50)
For the 10-sold row that’s ($8.94 + $0.45) ÷ 0.405 = $23.20. Fee rates change, so check Etsy’s own fees page before you set prices.
How do I guess how many will sell?
You don’t need an exact number, just a fair one. Some honest ways to set it:
- From your own records. If you’ve sold at markets before, count what you brought home last time. That is your first sell-through rate.
- By where the candles go. Made-to-order online sales usually leave few unsold candles. A market table needs a full display, and some of it will come home.
- By season. A pumpkin scent poured in November has a short shelf life. A plain unscented candle doesn’t.
If you have no history yet, try 10 of 12 and change it once you have a season of sales to look at.
What about the wax left in the pot?
Some wax always stays behind: the film on the pitcher, the drips, the last bit that is too cool to pour. Our pour day planner adds 5% extra wax and oil by default to cover it.
That extra 5% costs money too. For the example candle it adds about $0.12, taking the cost from $7.45 to $7.57. Twelve cents seems small, but over a year of batches it is real money.
Leftover wax doesn’t have to be wasted. Pour it into wax melt clamshells or a test jar, and if those are sold, count them as their own product.
How do I count test candles?
Test candles belong to the recipe, not to one batch. Say a new scent needs a three-wick test with two jars per wick. That is six jars. At the example materials cost of $5.05 per jar (wax, oil, jar, wick, label and box, without labor), the test costs about $30.32.
You can spread that over the first run of the recipe. If you expect to sell 48 of the new scent, add $30.32 ÷ 48 = $0.63 to each candle. The calculator has an overhead line for this kind of cost. The example uses $0.40 per candle for test candles, tools and a share of rent, so a busy testing season may need more.
Are samples a cost or marketing?
They are both, and either way they need paying for. If you give one sample candle to each shop you approach, you can count it in your unsold candles, as above, or put it under overhead as marketing. Just count it once. If it’s in overhead, don’t count it as an unsold candle too.
What if I sell the leftovers at a discount?
Then they aren’t fully unsold. Say two leftover candles sell at half price at the end of the season. They bring in money, but after fees they may barely cover their own cost. A fair way to plan: count them as unsold when you set the regular price, and treat anything the discount brings in as a bonus. That way the regular price doesn’t depend on a clearance sale.
Does shipping change any of this?
Yes, especially free shipping. A glass jar packed in a box with filler weighs much more than the candle inside. Find your packed weight with the shipping weight calculator. If you offer free shipping, add the postage to your cost before you apply the made-versus-sold step. Remember that postage for a sample or a replacement for a broken candle is a cost too.
Enter your real batch size and a cautious "expected to sell" number in the cost calculator, then compare the suggested price with what you charge today. If the gap is big, look at jars, packaging and minutes per candle first. Those are usually where the money goes, more than the wax.
Honest limits
These are planning numbers, not accounting advice. The example prices (wax at $3.20 a pound, oil at $2 an ounce, a $1.75 jar) are round numbers so the math is easy to follow. Put in what you actually pay. Fees, postage and your local tax rules change. Check Etsy’s fee page and your own records, and talk to an accountant about how to treat inventory and samples for tax.
Sources
- Etsy: Fees & Payments Policy, the $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee on price plus shipping, and payment processing charged on the total sale
- Etsy Help: payment processing fees, the US rate used in our fee formula
- CandleScience: Maker Business Hub, supplier guidance for selling candles